Skip to main content

Posts

To Catch a Thief (1954)

"This is nothing wrong with the film; it just isn't all that remarkable." -- McDevitt and Juan, A Year of Hitchcock Well, how's that for a ringing endorsement? This is maybe what happens when you start watching a bunch of films by the same director or the same actor. You naturally start comparing it with all the other films they've done, and that's fine, but when you do that, you may also lose sight of assessing the film solely on its own merits. Forget for a second that this is a Hitchcock film. Forget for a second that Cary Grant and Grace Kelly have been in other films. If you are just watching this film and if you are just assessing this film, is it any good or not? I think it is a good film. It has a solid premise with a great location. Beyond that, Grant and Kelly have good chemistry. Sure, Grant is a little too old for Kelly, really, but that aside, the film just works.  The way they use the color green is cool. I'm not sure what it's supposed t...
Recent posts

The Wrong Man (1956)

Henry Fonda's face. He can just walk into a room, turn around slightly, and show you the fear in his face. Why should Manny (Fonda) be afraid? The police remind him again and again that the innocent man has nothing to fear. They play good cop, good cop, pretending to be on his side. Of course they're not. Manny doesn't know any better than to trust them. When the police approach him on his doorstep, rather than just demand to go in to tell his wife that they want to question him at the station, he asks. They deny. They assure him that they've contacted his wife, but don't. All he does is cooperate and tell the truth, and it doesn't do any good.  Much of the movie makes it feel like even a completely honest person, a person who wants to be decent and live the right way, will never find a way to get ahead in this world. And what's so scary: Even a completely honest man can be pointed out in a line up.  But think about it: The people who pointed him out in the ...

I Confess (1953)

Apparently, the whole blackmail angle was added to the movie from the original play version. It's one of the parts of the plot I don't like, because although we can assume Michael (Montgomery Clift) and Ruth (Anne Baxter) have a sexual relationship in the past, there's really no way for Hitchcock to suggest they're having an ongoing affair. As a result, where does the blackmail come in? On top of that, Ruth's husband is so chill. Even when Ruth has to give her full history with Michael to the police in front of her husband, he never seems upset. He is there for her, and ultimately, we get the picture that she is loyal to her husband -- and loves her husband. Maybe not in the same way she loves Michael, but in a way that allows her to stay married and committed to him.  Ruth may have still have a deep love for Michael, but she's with his husband, and that's that.  Another interesting aspect: In the original play, Father Michael is hanged for the crime. In the...

Suspicion (1941)

Lina (Joan Fontaine) is supposed to be ugly, or at best plain. She wears glasses -- of course. She's an outsider. A loner. An old maid.  And then Johnnie (Cary Grant) falls into her lap. He's the playboy that every woman finds handsome and sexy. He undoubtedly takes advantage of his good looks, but he also finds his playboy lifestyle dull. Why else would he want to marry Lina? Lina makes the mistake not to vet Johnnie properly. If she just talked to the other girls, it wouldn't be hard to find out his flaws, but since they wed so quickly, she only learns after it's too late. At that point, she's committed to him, flaws and all. He lets her down, but seemingly always makes it up to her. Even when he sells her dad's priceless chairs, he buys them back. No matter that he lies about how he got the money to buy them back. At one point, Lina has had enough and writes him a Dear John letter, but she immediately tears it up. She knows he's an immature "boy,...

The 39 Steps (1935)

In their book A Year of Hitchcock, McDevitt and Juan suggest that this might be the film that first showcases Hitchcock working on all cylinders. And I would have to agree. The film has witty dialogue, and that might have been the most obvious addition that had been lacking in previous films.  When people talk about Hitchcock films, they often bring up his use of MacGuffins. In this film, for example, the "state secret" is important to the characters. It gives them reasons to do what they do, but it's never "revealed" what the secret is, or who wants it. And ultimately, it doesn't matter. As audience members, we are simply interested in following Hannay's (Robert Donat) journey -- his quest not only to stay alive, but to clear his name.  Mr. Memory (Wylie Watson), as it turns out, is the "microfilm." We assume that the secret might be hidden somewhere, in some place. When we see the opening of the film, we're probably not thinking much abou...

The Man Who Knew Too Much (1934)

  McDevitt and Juan offer five pages of "their impressions" on this film in their book A Year of Hitchcock. Although it includes a picture of Peter Lorre, they don't mention anything he actually does in the movie. Later in the chapter, the only thing they say about Lorre is that he didn't know English and had to memorize his lines phonetically. And yes, I would say that for someone who can't speak English, he's impressive.  The problem with his part in this film, however, is that he simply has nothing to do. I am a huge Peter Lorre fan, and I like to watch his films. Unfortunately, he's in a few films, like this one, where he really doesn't have much to make him stand out. Lorre "stands out," of course, just by the way he looks and his presence on the screen. But damn it, that's not enough. His character needs something to do, too.  In the 1956 remake with Jimmy Stewart and Doris Day, Hitchcock streamlines the story and makes it easier to...

The Lodger (1927)

The "first" Hitchcock film. As I'm reading through the Truffaut/Hitchcock book, I'm reminded that Hitchcock saw film as a visual medium. Maybe that's an obvious idea, but his point was that later, film would sort of forget that, and scenes would develop around people just finding different places to talk.  I've definitely noticed this without ever putting it into words. It's probably why I don't like shows like Law and Order, for example, but when I think of other shows I do like, I can see how some of them are more "talk shows," so to speak, than shows fully utilizing the visual to drive a story. Why does that happen? Likely because it's easier to convey information through talking (and probably because it's cheaper?). For Hitchcock, he believed that the fewer title cards needed in a silent film, the better. The challenge was to convey everything the viewer needed to know through a look, or to find other visual ways to communicate th...