In my search for films with Charles Grodin with good ratings, I stumbled upon this one. For whatever reason, I have a difficult time finding 1970s films that I want to watch. Why is that? I mean, I have no problems finding films from any other decade, but beyond the "best well known" films of the 1970s, I tend to draw a blank.
And this one, I would have thought, would be better known. It was nominated for 14 Oscars and won 9. But nope. I went in to watching it without having a clue what the plot was about. Nor did I know that this is a remake of Here Comes Mr. Jordan (1941), which features another one of my favorite actors, Claude Rains. (There's also a 1943 movie called Heaven Can Wait, but it has nothing to do with the 1978 version.)
Although I'm okay with fantasy, the premise of the film is a little absurd. I could forgive that, but I don't like how the ending is handled. In brief, Joe (Warren Beatty) is a back-up quarterback for the Los Angeles Rams. He's just found out that he's been picked to start the season, but then he's tragically killed. He doesn't realize that he's dead, and in questioning where he is, he soon finds out that it was a mistake. His spirit was removed before he was actually dead.
The kind agents of Heaven want to make up for the error, but his body has already been cremated. Why this should matter, I'm not sure, because his "body" would have already been buried. But anyway, they allow him to find a suitable just-dead body to put his soul into. It turns out to be a millionaire's body. He's in this guy's body for most of the movie, and he retains his own thoughts and memories. He even buys the Rams for $67 million dollars so that he can find his way to place himself in as starting quarterback for the Super Bowl, which is just about to happen.
In terms of the timeline, then, he's been this other guy for months. But this guy's wife and his executive assistant (Grodin) have long been planning to murder him. In the meantime, Joe has also fallen in love. So, it's no longer just that he wants to stay alive to be the Super Bowl quarterback, but he also wants to stay alive to be with the woman he loves.
But when the millionaire is killed, Joe has to enter another body. This time, for reasons never explained in the film, when he takes over the new body, he has to lose his own identity. He's prepared the woman that this might happen, so that she knows it's really him in a new body, but what difference does it make if he himself doesn't know that it's him?
I guess the ending is unnecessarily complicated. Let Joe continue to be Joe in the new post-millionaire's body, and I might like it a little bit better.
As is, I kind of felt like I was watching a made-for-TV movie, like those the networks used to make back in the 1970s and 80s. It's got Beatty and Julie Christie, but the overall quality of the film is only marginally better than a TV movie and it's difficult to believe that it actually got 14 Oscar nominations.
All that said, this is another remake that makes me want to go back and watch the original, if only just to see how the original handled things differently, and hopefully better.
Rating: 2/5 stars

Comments
Post a Comment