Surely Kate Winslet has been in a few duds, but if so, what are they? I usually feel like it's a mistake to watch a film just because an actor is in it. I mean, I do, but I'm often disappointed. I often wonder: Why on earth did they pick THAT role? Why did they agree to be in THAT movie?
It reminds me of actors like Bruce Willis who, at least at the end of his career, signed up to be in any movie that came his way. Granted, I get why Willis made that decision, but Winslet has never had to make that choice. She's always been able to pick provocative roles in good movies.
And this is a really good movie.
I did find myself saying "No... no... no..." when I realized that the film was about to end and the characters were all starting to make weird decisions. I don't believe, for example, that Sarah (Winslet) would go over to the child molester in the park late at night to see if he is okay. I don't believe that Brad (Patrick Wilson) would stop to do skating tricks when Sarah is waiting for him in the park. And no, I don't believe that Larry (Noah Emmerich) would offer his condolences to the child molester regarding his mother's death. All of those things happening right at the end of the movie were unexpected. Unexpected isn't bad, but nothing prepared me for those characters doing those things.
What I did really like was the use of Will Lyman as the story's narrator. He's got a great voice, and the narrative technique actually worked very well. The ending itself doesn't resolve much, and I wondered if the narrator could have had a little more to add at the end. Have Brad and Sarah decided, what? Have they decided to return to their own lives? For Brad, does this mean he will actually buckle down and become a lawyer? How in the world does Sarah move forward in her marriage? I guess I don't understand how they go so far and commit to being together, but then, nope, guess not. I recognize that taking the step to "run away" is a huge one, but are we to believe that they weren't right for one another, that everything they did together was simply a fantasy?
Who are the little children? Are they Sarah and Brad and Larry -- and basically all the adults? I mean I don't know if any of the "adults" in this movie act like adults, other than maybe May (Phyllis Somerville), and even her final note to her son is "Be a good boy."
I noticed that a lot of reviewers seem to want to compare this to American Beauty; I wasn't really thinking of that when I watched it. I do agree that this one is so very close to being a masterpiece but maybe falls just short. For me, it may boil down to the ending... I don't know. It's one of those endings that, if it went exactly as I expected, maybe that wouldn't seem realistic? But my expectation would be that Larry and Ronnie (Jackie Earle Haley) have it out. Brad and Sarah go off together, and their spouses wake up the next day to figure out what they do next.
And by the way, why did Brad still have the note in his pocket that he wrote to his wife. That should have been left at the house... it didn't make sense that he would still have it with him...

Comments
Post a Comment