When I watched this the first time in 2017, I ended up giving it a 2 out 5-star rating. I didn't write down any notes to explain my rationale, and so as I was re-watching the film now, I found myself trying to piece together how I might have rated it so poorly then.
This time around, I appreciated the set pieces, especially the State of Liberty ending. But the film had other "set pieces," and by that, I simply mean, Hitchcock clearly took some time to figure out how to best shoot the factory, the cabin in the woods, the dockyard, the dance floor, and so on. Good camera work. Good set up of scenes. Good lighting. Just a lot of "good stuff" that a 2-star film wouldn't have.
Did the movie lack anything, then? Well, it's a quiet film. When I think of Hitchcock, I think of the dramatic score. Try watching Psycho without the soundtrack. It wouldn't be nearly the same, right? I just wonder what a good musical score would add to Saboteur.
That might, in fact, be what got on my nerves the first time I watched. In that respect, although the movie came out in 1942, it has an early 1930s movie feel. On the other hand, the visuals and the way the film is shot feels maybe a little more like the 1950s. So here we have a film that feels a little dated but also a little ahead of its time.
Less important, the film doesn't have much star power. I don't recognize any of the actors. And that's okay, as they all do a better than adequate job, but just imagine if you had a Henry Fonda or a Jimmy Stewart or a Cary Grant (and the equivalent female costar).
In terms of plot, why are the bad guys helping the enemy? We never really find out their reasons. They're rich and they have a good life in the United States. If they live here and are helping blow up war factories, maybe that's one thing, but if they're behind trying to blow up dams and other important infrastructure, I'm just not sure why they would want to do that -- unless they're planning either to overthrow the government or leave the country.
Kane (Robert Cummings) is the falsely accused man. There seems to be a class theme embedded in the movie. It's easy to trust the rich and powerful -- maybe for the very reasons I've stated above -- why would they want to destroy the system that established them? -- but it's easy to distrust the working class -- because they have less to lose?
The travelling circus and the blind man are interesting touches. Both believe in Kane's innocence. For whatever reason, it doesn't take Patricia (Priscilla Lane) long to believe in Kane, too.
That ending. Why does Fry (Norman Lloyd) go to the Statue of Liberty? It's a symbolic target, if he's planning to blow it up, but if he is planning to blow it up, I must have missed that part. Compared to ships and dams and factories, it doesn't seem worth bothering with. I do like that Patricia recites part of the Statue of Liberty poem to Fry. This should remind him, and us, that the U.S. is the good guy. The bad guys are never mentioned by name. Why exactly would any American support what they want to achieve in the world?
As he hangs on by a literal thread, Fry promises Kane he will clear him. I'm not sure what he means by that. Maybe he doesn't know that Kane's been cleared already -- that the FBI have finally believed he's telling the truth. Maybe he says it simply in appreciation for Kane trying to save his life. I don't know. In any event, we have yet another premature ending. Fry might be out of the picture, but does that mean the whole syndicate is done now?
And not to nitpick, but why does Fry use his own name? That seems a little foolish. And using the regular mail to send correspondence to Charles? (Otto Kruger). Just careless.
All of its faults aside, this is better than a 2-star film, and I'm looking forward to making my way through the major films of Hitchcock one more time.
Rating: 3.5/5 stars

Comments
Post a Comment