Lina (Joan Fontaine) is supposed to be ugly, or at best plain. She wears glasses -- of course. She's an outsider. A loner. An old maid.
And then Johnnie (Cary Grant) falls into her lap. He's the playboy that every woman finds handsome and sexy. He undoubtedly takes advantage of his good looks, but he also finds his playboy lifestyle dull. Why else would he want to marry Lina?
Lina makes the mistake not to vet Johnnie properly. If she just talked to the other girls, it wouldn't be hard to find out his flaws, but since they wed so quickly, she only learns after it's too late. At that point, she's committed to him, flaws and all. He lets her down, but seemingly always makes it up to her. Even when he sells her dad's priceless chairs, he buys them back. No matter that he lies about how he got the money to buy them back.
At one point, Lina has had enough and writes him a Dear John letter, but she immediately tears it up. She knows he's an immature "boy," but that's Johnnie, and you either accept him as-is, knowing that he (hopefully) means well, or you just can't stay around him.
The suspicion builds as follows: He likes murder mysteries. We start to feel like he might be willing to kill anyone -- from his best friend to his own wife -- is that's what he needs to do to survive. And here, the Hays Code probably steps in and ruins the ending. Everything points to Johnnie killing Lina. It's fine if that's just her suspicion, and if it turns out that she's wrong about him, okay. She's been wrong about him before, after all. Why shouldn't she be wrong about him now?
Even so, the ending isn't at all satisfying. Johnnie admits that he's a no good so and so, and he seems sincere when he tells Lina he's better off without him. But this is just in a moment -- is he just saying what he needs to say --, and will Johnnie really change if Lina gives him another chance? She's willing to. She believes she was mistaken about him wanting to kill her, but she's not, remember, wrong about him being an immature boy. Has he really matured somehow by the end? It's hard to see how.
Nevertheless, Johnnie turns the car around, as Lina has asked. That's the ending, and I don't like it.
Fontaine also played Jane Eyre in 1943. Was she really seen as "plain" in Hollywood circles? As far as Suspicion goes, Lina is probably supposed to be 28 -- a definite old maid. It's harder to know what Johnnie's age might be. Cary Grant was 37, but it seems likely that Johnnie was either meant to be younger, or if he was in his 30s, then he's just a man who never grew up. He doesn't come across as a murderer, but he does at least come across as a guy who will do or say whatever to get what he wants. So then the question still remains: Are we to believe him at the end if he tells Lina he's nothing without her? If he has been do everything else short of murder, how big of a step is it for him to kill?
Rating: 3/5 stars

Comments
Post a Comment