Apparently, the whole blackmail angle was added to the movie from the original play version. It's one of the parts of the plot I don't like, because although we can assume Michael (Montgomery Clift) and Ruth (Anne Baxter) have a sexual relationship in the past, there's really no way for Hitchcock to suggest they're having an ongoing affair. As a result, where does the blackmail come in? On top of that, Ruth's husband is so chill. Even when Ruth has to give her full history with Michael to the police in front of her husband, he never seems upset. He is there for her, and ultimately, we get the picture that she is loyal to her husband -- and loves her husband. Maybe not in the same way she loves Michael, but in a way that allows her to stay married and committed to him. Ruth may have still have a deep love for Michael, but she's with his husband, and that's that.
Another interesting aspect: In the original play, Father Michael is hanged for the crime. In the movie, the jury doesn't find him guilty (although the judge finds the need to say he thinks the jury made a mistake). Michael leaves the courtroom, not necessarily vindicated to the public. When he exits, I feel like he's walking through a mob like Tippi Hendren walks through the birds. Exactly why is this crowd so pissed off at the verdict? Is Father Michael the O.J. Simpson of Quebec?
The ending is a bit much, too. Otto (O.E. Hasse) somehow shoots his wife Anna (Dolly Haas) in the middle of the mob. We haven't seen them arguing over whether Otto should turn himself in for the original killing. You get the idea that Anna wants him too, but it might help to see a little more interaction between the two. Why does Otto end up doing the original killing anyway? In the play, he does it because he's caught in the middle of a robbery, but I didn't catch that he was a burglar in the film, or that he would need to be involved in committing any crime. Otto and Anna aren't rich, but they are comfortable and thankful to be alive and in Canada, having survived World War II.
Clift is a noted method actor, and Hitchcock wasn't a fan of that school. But how could he not be? Clift is able to communicate all of his character's feelings with his face and Hitchcock does a wonderful job closing in on that face so that we can feel what Michael is feeling.
Oh, one last thing. I noticed that the entire film includes a musical score. Every scene is set to music, and after watching a few of the early Hitchcock films, which are completely quiet, this is very noticeable. While I do think a little "soundtrack" is helpful to a movie, this almost felt like too much... almost like a "laugh track" -- that is, when you notice it, that's about all you can notice, no matter how good the scene (or in the case of a laugh track, the jokes) are otherwise.
Rating: 3.5/5 stars

Comments
Post a Comment