Dr. Constance Petersen (Ingrid Bergman) is a well-respected psychoanalyst. She's also a woman. We're going to be reminded of each of her "identities" throughout the film. Bergman is 30 in this film, and we can assume the character she portrays in about that age. Although she would have no trouble finding a date -- her colleagues would be willing to take one for the team -- she's fully committed to her work. It's likely she's never even been kissed.
Then John Ballantyne (Gregory Peck) shows up, except he's calling himself Dr. Edwardes, the new head of the psychiatric facility. That's who we -- and Dr. Petersen -- assume he is for the first part of the film. He's a famous psychoanalyst, although no one apparently knows what he looks like, and it's not clear who hired him, or why the old head is leaving.
Nevertheless, he and Dr. Petersen immediately fall in love. Her "woman" side comes out, and she will muse that she can't understand what is happening to her, or how she let herself fall instantly in love with this guy.
Even when it turns out that Ballantyne isn't Edwardes, and doesn't even remember who he is, Petersen stands by him. Yes, she stays with him to help him figure out who he is and what caused him to pretend to be Dr. Edwardes, but she remains attached to him romantically, even saying that she "forgets" he's her patient.
By the way, at some point I'd like to go through all of the Hitchcock films and see which "first kiss" he films best. The Peck-Bergman kiss has to be up there. For this one, he does closeups on their eyes before they kiss. And they can't stop kissing each other for the rest of the film (at least by 1940s film standards).
Eventually, Ballantyne remembers who he is, and he is arrested and convicted for the murder of Dr. Edwardes. That's one reason he didn't want to know who he was, because he assumed it would reveal something bad. Petersen, of course, feels bad that the "cure" cost him his freedom, but she continues to believe he's innocent and that there is some other explanation for how Dr. Edwardes died.
I don't think Hitchcock likes courtroom scenes. He's able to cover the entire trial just by a quick closeup montage of Petersen testifying at the trial.
With the trial over, Dr. Petersen returns to work, and the old head of the facility has returned to his previous job since Dr. Edwardes is dead.
The big "reveal" of whodunnit "comes out of left field," as McDevitt and Juan put it in A Year of Hitchcock. Petersen puts some "puzzle pieces" together, confronts the person who murdered Dr. Edwardes, and then lives happily ever after with Ballantyne.
I do appreciate the "gun scene" at the end. Hitchcock uses an oversized hand and revolver, giving it the camera point of view as first it points at Dr. Petersen as she walks out of the murderer's office. Then the hand and revolver rotate to aim straight at the camera (and us -- and the man actually holding the gun). The film is shot in black and white, but when the revolver fires, the screen turns red for a split second, which is a cool and unexpected moment.
The "Salvadore Dali" dream sequence is pretty cool, too. McDevitt and Juan note that David Selznick, the film's producer, forced Hitchcock to cut 14 minutes of this sequence. While I'd still like to see that 14 minutes of footage, it seems like that might have been the right call. I'm sure it was all "interesting footage" in and of itself, an extra 14 minutes would definitely have added a lot of drag to the forward progression of the film.
All that might have been nice to add is a few more "clues" about who actually killed Dr. Edwardes before the reveal. In later films, Hitchcock is good about letting the audience know what to look for, letting the suspense build and yet not rely on "twist endings," so to speak. This ending almost felt like that -- a twist ending that wasn't properly prepared.
Rating: 3.5/5 stars

Comments
Post a Comment