Wow.
When I ask my non-movie-obsessed friends what their favorite Hitchcock film is, they will say Psycho, The Birds, and Rear Window. All good choices, for sure. I'm not sure how many of them, if any, have watched or even heard of Rebecca.
It's Hitchcock's first American film; the first of five films that would earn him an Academy Award nomination for Best Director. In fact, this film was nominated for 11 Academy Awards and won for both Best Picture and best Cinematography, black and white film.
Now, there is a little debate on whether this "counts" as a Hitchcock film, as he was the Director, but he wasn't given full control over the movie. Producer David Selznick insisted that the film follow the original novel as closely as possible. Hitchcock had written his up his own ideas in a treatment, but for the most part Selznick rejected anything that strayed too far from the book. Selznick only agreed to change the novel's ending so that the movie could pass the censorship rule of not letting the "bad guy" get away with a crime.
Mrs. de Winter (Joan Fontaine) is actually Maxim's (Laurence Olivier) second wife. His first wife, Rebecca, died under obscure circumstances that only become clear late in the film. He only chances on meeting the new Mrs. de Winter (she's never given a first name) while on vacation. She's depicted as almost a Jane-Eyre-type: modest background, plain, shy, and clumsy. She doesn't have any hobbies or skills to speak of. So why does Maxim, a rich Europe from a different world, fall for her?
I'm not sure we ever find out why, other than she's the exact opposite of what his first wife was like. The first wife might have seemed "perfect" in many ways, but she was definitely not someone that could be controlled, or that belonged in a marriage. She would have affairs and flaunt them in her husband's face... she might have even had an affair with her maid, who knows?
In terms of the head "maid," Mrs. Danvers (Judith Anderson) -- aka Danny -- is a severe Wicked Witch of the West type. Just a brilliant "villain" in the film. Did she have a relationship with the first Mrs. de Winter that crossed a line? I could see why some critics think it's inferred. I simply thought that Mrs. Danvers appreciated her employer -- maybe as the woman she wanted to be, or as the woman that someone in Mrs. de Winter's position should be?
Servant or "blue blood," it's easy to see that the second Mrs. de Winter's doesn't belong in this world. Fontaine gives a masterful performance showing us this just through her body language. She slumps and deflates; she looks down a lot. Her hair and clothing don't impress. It's funny, because Fontaine herself is a beautiful woman, but here she is being depicted as nondescript and dull -- and she would be cast this same way in Suspicion (1941, with Cary Grant) and Jane Eyre (1943, with Orson Welles).
I really like this movie. I like the cinematography, the use of miniatures to create the Manderley estate, and all the other little subtle visual tricks that Hitchcock was able to include.
Is this film as good as Psycho and Rear Window? I don't know, but it's really good. I think it deserves to be in the conversation.
Rating: 5/5 stars

Comments
Post a Comment